Saltar al contenido
People & Play
People & Play
People Analytics & AI

5 min de lectura

Vanity people metrics: the dashboard that applauds and never decides

Many people dashboards get applause in the committee and change no decision afterwards. David Botella explains how to tell a vanity metric apart from an indicator that actually drives decisions.

Screen with charts and metrics, a symbol of a people dashboard that needs judgement

David Botella

CTO · 28 Oct 2026

Índice de contenidos

1. Three numbers that applaud and don't steer2. When the dashboard rewards the snapshot3. The indicator that changes no decision4. A checklist before adding a KPI5. Questions a director should ask6. Closing the loop with an action

Three numbers that applaud and don't steer

Some people dashboards get applause in the committee and no decision afterwards. Wellbeing portal visits go up, completed trainings grow, a climate pulse score improves. Everything rises, yet nobody can point to what was actually done differently because of those numbers.

  • A vanity metric grows on its own and demands no action from leadership.
  • The problem isn't measuring too much, it's measuring what forces no decision.
  • A dashboard full of green bars can coexist with an organisation that never improves.

When the dashboard rewards the snapshot

We see people teams optimising the indicator instead of the problem. Survey participation going up gets rewarded, not unwanted turnover going down. More candidates in the pipeline get celebrated, not a shorter time to fill a critical vacancy.

That shift is quiet. Nobody decides to dress up the data, the committee simply ends up looking at the number that is comfortable to present.

  • Monthly reports with twenty charts and no actionable conclusion.
  • KPIs that improve on paper while the real problem stays intact.
  • Data teams reporting activity instead of impact.

The indicator that changes no decision

Our reading is simple: if an indicator rises or falls and no decision changes as a result, that indicator doesn't belong on the leadership dashboard. It can stay in an operational report, but not in the strategic conversation.

“A KPI that changes no decision doesn't measure performance, it measures the activity of the team reporting it.”

— David Botella

CTO at People & Play

That filter is uncomfortable because it forces you to retire metrics that have sat in the quarterly deck for years, simply because they were always there.

A checklist before adding a KPI

You don't need to redesign the whole dashboard. You need a filter before adding any new number.

  1. Ask which decision would change if the number moved
    • If the answer is none, the indicator doesn't go to the committee.
    • If the answer is vague, the action threshold needs defining first.
  2. Connect every metric to a real cost or risk
    • Unwanted turnover has a cost. An internal newsletter's open rate usually doesn't.
    • Without an associated cost, the indicator lives in the operational report, not the strategic one.
  3. Review the dashboard every quarter and drop what went unused
    • A metric nobody cited in three months of meetings doesn't need to stay.
    • Fewer indicators with more weight beat a full screen.

Questions a director should ask

Before approving the next people dashboard, it is worth asking:

  • What decision did we make the last time this indicator changed?
  • Does this number measure business impact or just the activity of the team reporting it?
  • How many of these metrics have gone over a year without triggering any change?
  • Does the committee discuss the number, or what the number should change?
  • What would happen if we removed half the charts in this report?

Closing the loop with an action

A people dashboard doesn't exist to generate applause in the committee. It exists to force decisions that would otherwise be postponed.

If you want to review your dashboard and keep only what truly moves decisions, let's talk. Usually half of it is excess, and what's missing is exactly the indicator nobody wants to look at.